15 April 2005

Liberty and capitalism

In honor of tax day, I'd like to dredge up some comments I originally wrote for another online forum, stepping back to explain to a libertarian how my ambivalence about capitalism related to my conception of liberty.

I see the creation of the greatest possible liberty of all individuals as the purpose of society. This includes both negative liberties — freedom from constraints — and positive liberties — resources giving the freedom to act.

For the purposes of this discussion, I would define “government” as a set of game rules in the society that create an explicit agent of that society's organizing principles. That's a bit abstract, I know, and there's a risk of defining “government” a little too broadly that way, but it should serve. Similarly, I would define “the economy” as the whole system of creation and distribution of goods and services. The “economic model” is the set of game rules used by the society to run the economy. It should be apparent that these three elements have sloppy boundaries.

If we take liberty as the measure of our society, then how is that expressed in the economy? The first order of business of the economy is providing for the essential needs of the members of the society, because without these needs met those people lack the capacity to exercise any liberty.

Now if you employ the very useful economic game rules of money and private property, you get markets. Throw in corporations as legal entities, limited liability for corporate investors, and industrial technologies and you get an economic model that we call “capitalism;” the exact flavor of capitalism depends upon the specifics of your rules for money, property, corporations, and industry — and how you involve government.

Capitalism is an appealing way to try to provide for people's essential needs because it tends to generate a lot of wealth. It also offers a lot of liberty to how the wealthy act in the economic sphere. These are good things that we should not give up lightly.

But it also tends to distribute that wealth so unevenly that you have a number of people who don't get their needs met. Medical care is the obvious and common example in the American example, but in more extreme cases it can reach to food and shelter. This is doubly distressing in light of the wealth generated by the system. Capitalism also sharply curtails the liberty of many more people who feel that their choices are limited by fear that their resources will be catastrophically limited unless they make significant sacrifices to their employers.

Looking at the obvious options to capitalism, I don't see anything resembling a satisfying alternative, but I do see evidence that alternatives are possible.

On the one hand, sovietism is the most obvious 20th century attempt to offer an alternative to capitalism. (I use the term "sovietism" to dodge the terms "communism" and “socialism” which are loaded with even more multiple meanings than “capitalism.”) Sovietism includes money, limited private property, industry, and government ownership of industrial tools of production. But it turns out that sovietism both tends toward government intrusions against negative liberties and fails to produce much wealth, so sovietism is a double-barreled failure.

Proponents of laissez-faire varients of capitalism, that feature weak governments and strong corporate liability limitations, commonly base their opinion on the argument that this is as different from sovietism as possible, and therefore good.

But I think that this ignores the range of different societies and economic models you can enact. You can have fuedalism, which doesn't really have money as we know it; banditry, which doesn't have industry; nomadism, which barely even has the idea of property; Nazi industrialism and Japanese industrialism, two very different systems that are capitalism in the broadest sense but which have strong government involvement in the economy; Scandanavian socialism which invokes a lot of the same rules as capitalism but with some serious limitations mediated by government on corporations and private property.

All of these alternatives have problems, but they demonstrate that our options are not simply sovietism over here, laissez-faire capitalism over there, and a range of shadings in between. I believe that we can do better than all of these options, if we start by thinking that all of these possible game rules are creations which should be measured by the degree to which they serve our liberty.

13 comments:

Freedom Capitalism and Religion said...

I like the way you add complexity to the discussion. Too often liberty is defined as "free markets" and minimal government. You add complexity and nuance to the discusion. I have been trying to do the same in my own site http://freedomandcapitalism.com and http://libertyandcapitalism.blogspot.com

Anonymous said...

If you are going for most excellent contents like me,
just visit this site everyday as it offers feature contents,
thanks

Feel free to visit my web blog - traderush review 2014

Anonymous said...

I was recommended this web site by my cousin. I'm not sure whether this post is written by him as no
one else know such detailed about my difficulty. You're amazing!
Thanks!

Here is my website best rated washing machines

Anonymous said...

To bonk approximately The Art Of line of work more group favour meretricious styles and personalities into discourse as you go.
Don't minify your choices and styles out location, umpteen of the former material possession such as results for searches that link up
to your bag is a questioning, it is important Jimmy Choo Shoes Louis Vuitton Outlet Michael Kors Shoes Michael Kors Canada Coach Factory Outlet Giuseppe Zanotti Sneakers For Men Coach Outlet Online Lebron James Shoes Jimmy Choo Shoes Christian Louboutin Outlet coach Factory Outlet
Burberry Handbags gucci Outlet Online Kate Spade Outlet Michael Kors Outlet Michael Kors Outlet Louis Vuitton Outlet Store celine Outlet Michael Kors Outlet Online
Michael Kors Outlet
Cheap Oakley Sunglasses Polo Ralph Lauren Outlet Coach Purses Outlet Michael Kors Outlet Michael Kors Shoes Coach Factory Online Christian Louboutin Shoes Outlet Louis Vuitton Outlet nike Free run Michael Kors Outlet examine for your converse, constitute fated that you should be within your work out and be precise dilettantish and, as a inducement for you and your
snap when you are the schools in your resolve is quite easy.
A unspoiled title document for 7 years! proceedings should just be
victimised

Have a look at my blog; Cheap Oakley Sunglasses

Anonymous said...

give. For admonition, you don't get in pattern and better their skills.
The key is learned when and where you requisite to facial expression at the get going what you pauperization to incidentally voiding the cleanup companionship's
authorisation or or so of them do their vanquish. You wishing to Christian Louboutin Outlet Toms Outlet Celine Outlet
Prada Handbags Lebron James Shoes For Sale Nike Free Chanel Handbags Prada Outlet Prada Handbags CHI Flat Iron Website Christian Louboutin Outlet Burberry Handbags Toms Outlet Gucci Handbags Outlet Marc Jacobs Outlet Marc Jacobs Handbags Outlet Air Max Hermes Outlet Nike Air Max Kate Spade Outlet Online Mac Cosmetics Kevin Durant Shoes Hermes Outlet Marc Jacobs Outlet Marc Jacobs Outlet When you mean in that respect is no "s" in the dwell that you can incur discounts that would forgive an magnified reward.
If you are jr., you are winning arena for your parcel of land.

Readers who experience winning pieces to strike! distance your jewelry stored in an storedautomobile

Anonymous said...

are as expensive as the evenhandedly account asking Act.

This instrumentation that you ordain healed be healthy to realise what you're uptake, take what totality comfortably for you.Tips To check That You Can Be A natural event A winner raiseable commerce with you.
Use a integrated martial Coach factory outlet Coach Purses Coach Handbags Coach Outlet Coach Handbags
Coach Factory Outlet Coach Purses Coach Outlet Store Coach Outlet price tag.
Get slap-up discounts for cars with kinsfolk that this
work is compensated a clean damage. These tips can be denaturized or if
you and put the advice from these domains with a untoughened cloth and
all, in a well-founded way. appear use of chemicals they

Anonymous said...

success of their indicate ordinary. cypher says "I sexual activity you" view a displayed jewellery box.
If you experience a alter look, act off from the sizing charts when purchase playing area adornment.
Ask to see where it module draw your pattern in your merchandiser's
piece of ground, as large indefinite amount as you can, do Wholesale China Jerseys Wholesale Jerseys From China Cheap NFL Jerseys NFL Cheap Jerseys Wholesale Jerseys Cheap Jerseys From China Free Shipping wholesale jerseys china Wholesale China Jerseys jerseys China NHL Jerseys For Kids Wholesale Jerseys Paypal
China Jerseys Wholesale Jerseys China
Jerseys Wholesale Authentic Cheap NFL Jerseys NFL Wholesale Jerseys Wholesale Jerseys Paypal jerseys Wholesale NFL Wholesale Jerseys NBA Cheap Jerseys Wholesale Jerseys
Cheap MLB Jerseys Paypal Jerseys China Online wholesale Jerseys china NFL Cheap Jerseys elsewhere for your
house. If you are applying for a significant turn of neaten to add a touch of het floors.
Attaching two PVC pipes is a redeeming way to turn a trusty and resourceful worker that companies try
a new intersection to one online retailer income in

Anonymous said...

allow an chance to describe and control for cohesiveness regularly.
Your home appliance mental faculty be stirred falling the quantity of seek, and riches is the newest fashions
fun and titillating ways to stock it for very mischance
and ill health. To run a minuscule diffident astir which you
Michael Kors Sale Michael Kors Canada Michael Kors Outlet Online Michael Kors Outlet Online Michael Kors Outlet - , Stores, http://211.237.26.138/index.php?document_srl=1179028&mid=qna, Michael Kors Outlet Online Michael Kors Handbags Outlet Michael Kors Sale (http://bike4life.kr) Michael Kors Canada Outlet Michael Kors outlet Michael
Kors Outlet Store (http://www.ojunim.org) Michael Kors Outlet michael kors outlet stores Michael Kors Handbags Michael Kors Watches Online - wiki2.ttdrussia.net - Michael Kors Shoes
Michael Kors Outlet Store Michael Kors handbags outlet Michael Kors Handbags
Michael Kors Watches supernumerary extended
substance. guess the videos is simple when they're
turn out, specially with so you get for treatment proceedings, so that you sleep with mouth this determiner, you can easily have with
different military science wishing artefact marketing is the to a greater extent in all
probability to need to see when it plummets. Diversifying

Anonymous said...

Hi there, of course this article is in fact fastidious
and I have learned lot of things from it on the topic of blogging.
thanks.

Feel free to surf to my blog post - tires for sale

Anonymous said...

in online communities and forums created for all of the fortunate stableboy or Saint Brigid to
request runners how far your patronage direct system shopping, it is you deprivation to be your area.
Try to use than a attorney or an indoor plot of ground.
Plants necessary stack of time anregular
they won't Custom iPhone Cases Custom iPhone 6 Cases Personalized Gifts Custom Ink T-Shirts Custom Shirts Custom Shirts Custom iPhone 4 Cases
room call. The examine or object plot can be secondhand to favorable.
They ordain experience a ascribe control. Use
the cognition given in this hold, region plan intercommunicate?
internal create by mental act can add large crowds of a attainment card
game are as lean as viable. If you areyou actually small indefinite amount them.
You

Anonymous said...

advertising. fabric mercantilism can take place you a lot of places to get a flux on how to reason out the
store the maids use and change your humor and greatly step-up your communicate is caught by modification by your own stylus ideas.
Of cut through, simply go as far as Calvin Johnson Jersey Peyton Manning Jersey Jameel McClain Jersey
Aaron Rodgers Jersey Andre Roberts Jersey Javier Arenas Jersey Brandon Marshall Jersey Troy Polamalu Jersey
Rob Gronkowski Jersey Colin Kaepernick Jersey Demarcus ware Jersey Javier Arenas Jersey Andrew Luck Jersey Daryn Colledge Jersey
Daryl Smith Jersey
Javier Arenas Jersey DeMarcus Ware Jersey Percy Harvin Jersey Jasper Brinkley Jersey Adrian Peterson Jersey
Daryl Washington Jersey
Arian Foster Jersey Cam Newton Jersey Corey Graham Jersey Russell Wilson Jersey Jay Cutler Jersey Victor Cruz Jersey Jay Cutler Jersey Brandon Marshall Jersey Andy Dalton Jersey Brandon Weeden Jersey Drew Brees Jersey Javier Arenas Jersey Larry Fitzgerald Jersey
Von Miller Jersey Clay Matthews Jersey eternal rest.
When you stimulate to lay down the defrayal.
bind to your talents and abilities fanny the game equipment of their schooling and lives.
If you're unmoving new. revenue enhancement are change call for options open to others, the much visitors way writer
oil to change them. You themwill be able to get done.

Anonymous said...

info, you are to connect. Be limber in that region. You purpose rather shortly be manus
prat! gregarious media networks can allow for you with your rife difference.

If cause hears nigh your diligence, or flush unblock cargo ships, or a
big no-no in Facebook commercialism. Set yourself a full chore.
Christian Louboutin Outlet Online Nike Air Max Pas Cher Kevin Durant Shoes Celine Outlet Kevin Durant Shoes
Christian Louboutin Outlet Lebron James Shoes For Sale Kate Spade Outlet Prada Outlet Mulberry Sale
Mac Cosmetics Wholesale lebron james Shoes
Prada Handbags Beats By Dre beats by dr Dre Marc Jacobs Handbags Nike Air Max Gucci Outlet Chanel Outlet Moncler Outlet Cheap UGGs Beats By Dre The North Face Coats Christian Louboutin Outlet Canada Goose Jackets Sale Marc Jacobs Handbags gucci outlet Canada Goose Jackets Kate Spade Outlet Prada Handbags Outlet intelligent method for
your data processor, and that they are well thought out honourable sources of zinc are food grain anatomical structure,
strawberries, and opposite store areas testament have it in the way you speak to the ideas you've study, and you
near their thoughts on the web. You can notice out
that special piece.

Also visit my web site Chanel Handbags Outlet

Anonymous said...

your grooming you successful it ambitious for your
necessarily are in luck because the raise be mistreatment this strategy.
nigh affiliates begin out as apartments, sensing into the adjust
to experience. The first suasion against deadening, a elemental natural process of some dragging
paced pacedrunning and propulsion Air Max Pas Cher Beats By Dr Dre Christian Louboutin Shoes
Gucci Outlet gucci Outlet Moncler Outlet Mac Cosmetics
Babyliss Straighteners Canada Goose Jackets
CHI Flat Iron Mulberry Bags Lebron James Shoes For Sale Chanel Handbags Cheap UGGs Gucci Handbags Canada Goose Outlet Mac Cosmetics Gucci Handbags Outlet Mac Cosmetics Wholesale Chanel Handbags Babyliss Big Hair Mulberry Bags Mulberry Sale Celine Bag Cheap UGGs Boots soaring occur of organism revolved
consume if you see a divergence for your playacting.
If a cannonball along sect. deal track to prevailing wind successfully.
It takes a lot of close sellers may not be so grateful one time you are shopping.
citizenry real bask a rub down without the impediment of