23 December 2012

Not-So-Good Men Project

I've been mildly interested in the feminist-informed web magazine for fellas The Good Men Project since it first turned up a few years back. I took a look at it early on, and I've read a handful of articles there, but every time I swing by there I conclude that I'm not really its audience. They're clearly trying to reach Regular Guys and the universe of gender politics culture that I move in is sufficiently weird and rarefied that they clearly weren't talking to me. But I've been kind of hazily glad they exist, since we need more and better feminist propaganda directed at men.

I'm not glad of them any more.

A day or three ago a Facebook friend linked to Amanda Marcotte's Slate article Rapists Say They Rape Because of Mixed Signals, and the Good Men Project Believes Them. The articles in question were Nice Guys Commit Rape Too and I'd Rather Risk Rape Than Quit Partying, looking at the narratives many men who rape construct about receiving mixed signals from women. I took a quick look at Marcotte's article and the two articles in question, and it seemed to me that Marcotte was reading them wrong; I took The Good Men Project as reporting what those rapists' rationalizations were, not accepting them. I have a lot of ambivalence about Marcotte already — she's a good polemicist, but not always good with nuance — so I thought that this was just a case of her tendency toward absolutism.

I was also hesitant to buy the critique because it connects to something which has recently given me an itch in the feminist blogosphere.

A lot of predatory men talk about “mixed signals” when a close look at what they say and do reveals that they are just engaging in self-serving, disingenuous rape apology bullshit where there was not really an opening for confusion at all. In the wake of recent studies showing that rapists will readily admit to having raped women if you don't call it “rape”, the feminist blogosphere has been talking about this rape apology move a quite a bit lately.

But in that discussion I have sometimes heard the implication that men talking about mixed signals are never doing anything other than rape apology. I disagree and think that, without taking it as a justification for rape, we have to include some thinking about how women do send mixed signals in order for us to fully understand how rape culture works. We have a culture hostile to women sending clear signals, and all men in our society have had troubling experiences with that. The pressure on women to send mixed signals, and the experiences men have with that, contribute to the machinery of rape culture in at least a couple of ways. It creates the opening for predatory men to rationalize to themselves the rapes they commit. And it makes those predators' claims of “mixed signals” plausible-sounding to responsible men when those responsible men don't stop to think about it carefully enough.

I took Marcotte's piece as belonging to that genre of reducing discussion of mixed signals to being nothing more than rape apology, shrugged, and let The Good Men Project off the hook.

I was wrong. I should have looked closer.

Last night I was talking to some friends about this dustup, so this morning I took another look at the Good Men Project articles. Looking at them, I still think that Marcotte's headline was a bit unfair in suggesting that the Good Men Project held that the rapists' stories were justified. The Good Men Project was quite clear that what these men had done was rape, and wrong.

But that didn't make those Good Men Project articles okay. They were very sloppy and strange and ... yeah ... rape-apologetic. So the criticism that Marcotte made in the body of her article had real bite.

I had thought that The Good Men Project had been critiquing the error of thinking that real mixed messages made rapists' rationalizations sound plausible, but in fact they had fallen for that error. And in misreading what the controversy was about, I had fallen for it too.

I did a little more digging and found more good commentary. Jill Filipovic writing at the UK Guardian lays out the critique well.

Feminists, including myself, pushed back on Royse's narrative. In response, the Good Men Project doubled down (and then tripled and quadrupled down). Good Men Project editor Joanna Schroeder made the decision to publish, under the cover of anonymity, the firsthand account of an admitted and unrepentant rapist who enjoys his hard-partying lifestyle and says he has “accepted a certain amount of rape as the cost of doing business.” Then they put up several more posts justifying the decision to publish the Royse piece and the rapist's narrative.

When women and men who have dedicated their lives and careers to anti-rape work pointed out the fact that we have some pretty good scholarly sources that look at why men rape, the Good Men Project editors responded by attacking the scholarly sources. Some GMP writers quit the site in protest. Other GMP editors and writers joined forces with Men's Rights Activists to lash out at feminists and anti-rape activists on Twitter and other social media.

....

So why am I writing about a relatively insular blog fight in my Guardian column? Because it sheds light on just how toxic our culture is when it comes to rape and sexual assault – and how we can fight back.

At Feministe, Filipovick has more about why The Good Men Project was speaking irresponsibly and responded badly to criticism and Thomas Macaulay Millar has a good critique of the framework which the Good Men Project offers for understanding rapists' behavior. At Heteronormative Patriarchy For Men, Ally Fogg calls shenanigans on the Good Men Project's article. At Jezebel Katie J. M. Baker offers strong words about why we should turn our backs on the Good Men Project.

I agree. The Good Men Project have demonstrated that they are not a trustworthy source.

20 comments:

Yewtree said...

Interested in your thoughts on "mixed signals" here. Could you elaborate?

Jonathan Korman said...

Yewtree, I have a long post on the subject, which is can also be found under the all men in our society link in this post.

Anonymous said...

Please let me know if you're looking for
a article writer for your blog. You have some
really great posts and I think I would be a good asset.
If you ever want to take some of the load off, I'd love to write some articles for your blog in exchange for a
link back to mine. Please shoot me an e-mail if interested.
Many thanks!

Also visit my blog post :: http://www.acapellagold.com

Anonymous said...

Anyone anywhere in the world who loves to cook and who is interested in learning how to cook Filipino food recipes only needs a working internet connection in order to be able to access and download famous
Filipino food or. To make your own baby shampoo at home, you'll need:.
You'll be able to cook a lot of meals not having adding heat for your definitely scorching apartment or house.


Here is my web page recipes every man should know pocket miami companions ()

Anonymous said...

Your style is very unique in cmparison to other folks I have
reead stuff from. Many thanks for posting when you have the opportunity, Guesas I'll
just bookmark this web site.

Also visit my homepage :: m88sb

Anonymous said...

Perhaps in the field of syncing your music library, it can be
a good alternative. It is possible to make the most
of all the totally free applications and use expert software program applications.


my webpage :: cydia ios 7 (dreamstar.co.kr)

Anonymous said...

There are new studies that say otherwise on coffee consumption. An imbalanced p - H
affects the cellular activity in the body, leading to the progression of most degenerative
diseases, including cardiovascular disease and heart disease, high blood pressure, high cholesterol levels, kidney stones, urinary incontinence, arthritis,
osteoporosis, cancer, diabetes, systemic weight gain and obesity.
However, wine certainly isn't for everyone and may
cause some medical conditions to worsen.

Also visit my web site - radio monitoring

Anonymous said...

I needed to thank you for this very good read!!
I certainly enjoyed every little bit of it. I have you book-marked to check out new stuff
you post…

Here is my blog post p90x versus insanity

Anonymous said...

Yesterday, while I was at work, my sister stole my apple ipad and tested to see iif
it can survive a forty foot drop, just so she can be a youtube sensation. My apple
ipad is now broken annd she has 83 views. I know this is totally
off topic but I had to share it with someone!

Have a look at my web sitte - starlink Best buy hdmi cable Reviews

Anonymous said...

I used to be recommended this blog by way of my
cousin. I'm now not sure whether or not this put up is written by him as nobody else realize such detailed approximately my trouble.
You are wonderful! Thanks!

Also visit my weblog ... Green Cleanse Review (houseofprayeronline.org)

Anonymous said...

Siegel aalso questioned the treue motivations of masny electronic cigarette opponents.

Thhe electronic cigarette hass been in survival for almost three years and is a quick device expected aat providing smokers with a healthier option. The user can smoke at hospitals, airports and at
any place without any being restricted.

Stop by my web blog :: prezzi delle sigarette

Anonymous said...

I аm regular νisitor, how aree you evеrybody? This ρiece оf writing posted
at this site is actually nice.

My homepage; emotional strain keeping; ,

Anonymous said...

Every weekend i used to pay a quick visit this web site, because i want enjoyment, since this this
site conations in fact nice funny information too.

my website: what is the best body cleanse

Anonymous said...

Νote: Users can cause ѕtaartup profіles andd test
different configսrations by loading saved ρгofiles.
You coulԀ also usee alteгnative partƴ computer
mɑintenance tiols for enhancing the speed and gratification ߋf one's computеr.
Thiѕ meant anybody coulԀ develop their օwn bгowser with all
the Netscape skeleton.

Feel free tо visit my blog; LogonStudio download

Anonymous said...

I'm gone to convey my little brother, that he should
also pay a quick visit this web sikte on regular basis to geet updated
from hottest news.

Feel free to surf tto my web blog; latest world at arms hack

Anonymous said...

Currently it appears like Movable Type is the best blogging platform out there right now.
(from what I've read) Is that what you're using on your blog?


Visit my web site :: goji pro funciona

Iknowyou said...

Strange thing, I saw your profile I translated it to read "I am a cunt", then I read your blog and though "yup"

Anonymous said...

Rather than getting better, the health insurance pool.

If you have paid in advance. With stock markets going on bumpy ride, regular car
accidents, riots, terrorist attacks -- which are expected too rise again over the coming years.
Although these are not the abc only things that Americans distrust.


My page; ubezpieczenia zawodowe (www.qandq.net)

Anonymous said...

Hi, always i used to check weblog posts here early in the dawn, because i love to find out more
and more.

Visit my blog ... natural anti aging products

Anonymous said...

Very shortly this web page will be famous
among all blogging people, due to it's good posts

Also visit my web page muscle mass